Friday, August 31, 2018

Why the Kenyan One-Stop-Border-Posts (OSBPs) must establish fire stations

Author Reference: Lango, B. (2017). Why the Kenyan One-Stop-Border-Posts (OSBPs) must establish fire stations. Disaster Management Series Journal. Nairobi, Kenya. January 27, 2018.
Intel Fire Group of Companies staff testing a fire hydrant. [Photo: courtesy]
 The One-Stop-Border-Post (OSBP), a concept that was replicated from Southern African countries to East African selected borders, is one that was tried and successful in reducing transport costs incurred in cross-border movement. The OSBPs which works on a simple concept of clearance at the entry country has also reduced the number of middlemen loitering around the border-points in search of “assisting” cross border customers with the tedious process. The OSBPs have been voted as the best trade implementations that are gearing the East African economies to achieving a steadfast rise in modern 24-hour system of operations at the cross borders. The OSBPs within the Kenyan borders are listed by the Kenya state department of public works as Kenya-Tanzania border :Lunga Lunga / Horohoro; Loitoktok/ Tarakea; Namanga/Namanga; Isebania/ Sirare; Taveta/ Holili and Kenya – Uganda border: Malaba/Malaba; Busia/Busia. The Kenyan OSBPs like the other OSBPs have major power installations which includes generators, and power-controlled backup system. None of the OSBPs have a fire station as part of its border post departments but nearly all have police post within the border post. In cases of fire emergencies it is paramount that the OSBPs will suffer a major setback in terms of emergency response mechanisms. In line with being proactive in its operations, the OSBPs should consider the institutionalization of fire department within its levels of operations to avert the possible risks. And this the OSBPs have to do either immediately or in the near future as growth in operations signals the expanded risks which include fire risks.
 
The long distance between the nearest fire station and the OSBPs
It is important to note that most of Kenya’s county headquarters which host fire stations, are not located at the border points of the country. In this sense therefore most of the OSBPs are Kilometers away from the nearest fire station. Take example of Taveta OSBP and the fact that Taita-Taveta county does not have a viable fire response mechanism leaves the OSBP with the nearest fire station being in Mombasa County which is slightly over 260Km away. Another case is the Lunga Lunga OSBP with its nearest fire station being the Kwale County which is headquartered in Kwale which is over 90Km away. The capacity of fire stations within the counties where the OSBPs are located also threatens the operations of the OSBPs as these services cannot be rendered as required. Busia and Malaba OSBPs will greatly benefit from the nearest fire station as the stations are located within reach but again the stations lack capacity in terms of personnel and resources.

Minor fire outbreaks within the OSBPs and the no-mans’ land
Minor fire outbreaks and accidents have been reported in the recent past at the various border posts within Kenya. These fire outbreaks requires a department that deals with fire and risks management stationed at the border point to reduce the time limit it takes the fire station to respond otherwise they may result into major incidences. Reports from various studies and reviews also showed that the land occupation where neither the Kenyan nor its neighbors laws applies as it borders both countries is prominent with small fires and especially in Busia and Malaba borders. The consequences of search fires should they escalate will affect both the OSBPs on each side of the countries. Emergency risks at the OSBPs does not only limit self to fire but entails a lot more. The risks which are consider minor at the OSBPs would include vehicle and track accidents, OSBPs water shortage delivery, OSBPs monthly inspections of safety equipment, OSBPs monthly safety meeting sensitization, OSBPs community safety awareness, and other safety facilitations that are undertaken at the post. The strategic positioning of a fire station at the OSBPs on the Kenyan borders will ensure it maintains the safety of the facilities that have cost the countries and their partners billions of money.
 
Cross-border and Sub-county guidelines on seeking support services during emergencies
As far as the knowledge of the author limits, when a country seeks cross border assistance it means that the country does not have the ability at the time or in a long period of time to handle its deficiency in the area it is requesting assistance. In order also for a country’s sovereignty not to be undermined it should be able to provide emergency services to its citizens and visitors. Cross-border operations of one country into another country’s territory is therefore one process that can take long and when it is an emergency such as fire risk then the pivotal need would averted. In a nutshell this writing suggest that it is impossible for an OSBP to rely on another country’s facilities in ensuring fire safety. In the Kenyan administrative systems the counties are sub-divided into sub-counties with sub-administrative organs which have devolved functions and one of this function is the fire service delivery. Despite the counties facing challenges in instituting the various sub-county fire department it is prudent for the OSBPs to work with the county government in the establishment of fire services at the county levels to their interest.

Cost involved in hiring external fire service providers
The OSBPs through their administrative organs and partners have the option of hiring private fire service providers on contract to provide the vital on-watch-24hour service. To the service providers this is a business whose major deliverable will be the nights spent without any incident of fire to respond to and amount of consultancy fee attached to it as the beneficiary of such a “sacrifice”. It should be noted that to the service providers, the author included, the sole objective is to make money and money it is they will make. It boils down to cost of having a fire station at the OSBPs and this should not be looked at in face value but the greater value and the cumulative benefits of maintaining the facilities. The question is “what is the real value of establishing a fire department at the OSBP vis-a-viz the hiring of fire service providers?” and the answer will determine the value of the properties. It is a strong belief of the author that the OSBPs in Kenya would be better off with a fire department within the station rather than a private fire service provider as the benefits, responsibilities, authorities, and accountabilities are way more. The choice remains for the OSBPs and their administrators but as a reason it should be noted that choices have consequences.

The need to educate the surrounding communities on fire safety
The safety and security of the OSBPs and their environments is solely dependent on the surrounding communities and its dependents. The risks that is involved in fuel syphoning and the burglaries within the OSBPs and their surrounding areas should fuel the need to educate the surrounding communities on safety and especially fire safety when it comes to fuel syphoning. Community policing established at the OSBPs and the surrounding communities would benefit to a bigger extent. Community safety awareness requires consistent trainings, follow-ups, and demonstrations on fire safety issues and how these issues are solved or controlled within their midst. The fire risks that surround most OSBPs includes fuel syphoning; burglaries; vehicle accidents; illegal cooking by truck drivers; roadside kiosks using open flammable fuels; and many others. 

In conclusion, it is important for the Kenyan OSBPs to establish fire stations within the posts to ensure rapid response and in the same breath model a culture that gives priority to safety within the border posts minding that fire service delivery is a free service but the consequences are never free of will.

The writer is a PhD Generalist in Project Management Specializing in Managing Disaster Projects using PMIS.
Contact: benard.lango@gmail.com

Sunday, June 3, 2018

Lango, B. (2018). Gender Mainstreaming in Distribution of Portable Fire Equipment. Benard Lango Disaster Management Projects Series: Nairobi, Kenya. June 3, 2018.



Author Reference
Lango, B. (2018). Gender Mainstreaming in Distribution of Portable Fire Equipment.  Benard Lango Disaster Management Projects Series:  Nairobi, Kenya. June 3, 2018. 
Gender is an emotive topical issue not only in Kenya but all around the world due to the subdued influence of one on the other and the benefits or lack of it that comes with it. The fact that most workplaces encourages gender – equity in all their operations, this has not been efficiently done when it comes to the distribution of portable fire equipment. A recent study through a consortium of insurance students of African Nazareen University in Kenya found out that most disadvantaged gender is the female and they tend to rely on their male counter-parts in terms of risk aversions. These assertions can be proved by studying the composition of the security department within the workplace where the majority would always be male while there female counters are employed to complete the equation only when necessary. The implementation of portable fire equipment in many workplaces have always assumed that both genders have equal response-ability in terms of disasters while the essence is that they have the same responsibilities. Response-ability and responsibilities should not be confused as these two determine the levels at which risks are usually averted. The availability of fire equipment does not always mean that there is an ability of the response capacities based on the workplace staff responsibilities. If this is the case, then the property of focus is as dead as the two thirds gender rule in Kenya. The various portable fire equipment that are available for use at the workplaces are mainly fire extinguishers; resistant blankets; sand buckets and in more modern institutions the fire beaters; and sweep treks. These equipment must be distributed appropriately and more so be distributed in consideration to the gender composition of the location.

It must be coined that the term gender in disaster management draws cultural based expectations on the roles of males and females in disaster risk management. Traditionally therefore women and men are usually associated with different roles in the society. While men tend to carry the heavy duties and literally heavy items within their environment and these in essence includes the fire equipment. When a disaster strike the men bear the greatest responsibilities and more so if it is the workplace. Gender mainstreaming should be a reality in workplaces that have deployed heavy portable fire equipment to offer a pluralistic solution that takes into consideration the diversity among men and women. The most common fire extinguisher found in most Kenyan workplaces are the 9kg ABC dry chemical, the 5kg CO2 gas, 9litre water type, 9litre foam type, and to a small extent the 2kg CO2 gas. In a typical workplace the most available would be the 5kg CO2 gas intertwined with the 9kg dry chemical powder type of which in most cases are only driven by business. The standard gross weight for the 5kg and 9kg fire extinguishers are 11.8kg and 14.9kg respectively for CO2 gas and dry chemical type fire extinguishers. Mainstreaming gender therefore would mean that the female are majorly disadvantaged in using the above equipment as the weight would be enormous. The current Kenyan workplaces are yet to take the gender imbalance into their portable fire equipment installations but more so on the installation of fire extinguishers.

The Gender Rule
The World Bank in its online GAD policy framework notes that men and women differ in legal, social and economic rights and these disparities are found in all workplaces and hampers men and women in various ways which includes adequate response to emergencies using portable fire extinguishers. In order therefore to bridge this gap it is important to reflect these disparities in workplace safety policies, regulations and even laws being enacted. It should be a policy for every organization and workplace where there is gender disparity that the distribution of fire extinguishers takes into consideration the strengths and the weaknesses of the various genders. There is a general assumption that “what men can do, women can do better” but this can only be true when one is given a favorable environmental conditions hence the need to provide equity. The society at large in the implementation of any project considers groups of people regarded as the disadvantaged. These groups commonly referred to as the highly vulnerable groups includes: children; women; the elderly; and the disable. Any risk mitigation strategy must take into consideration the response-ability of these groups within any setting. The children, disable, and elderly may not be more common at the workplaces or places of work but women certainly are. Prudence therefore directs that where there is gender disparity it is important that the distribution of the portable fire equipment takes into account these facts.

Many arguments have been fronted on the idea of gender mainstreaming to ensure equal opportunity for both sexes but it must not be lost that most businesses are geared towards profit making and where this is not a possibility then it would easily be ignored. The other fact that will be fronted would be the existence of risk aversion teams within the workplace hence no need for gender mainstreaming in distribution of portable fire equipment within the workplace. To this it should be noted that men and women are different and emergencies within the workplace does not follow any pattern neither does it waits for the risk aversion team, therefore risk response is a collective responsibility. Gender mainstreaming in disaster management is a reality that the players in the industry must take into consideration going forward.

Benard Lango, PhD Projects Management, MA. PPM
An accomplished Project Management researcher in the field of public safety service delivery specializing
in PMIS use in disaster management, Author of several books and articles, A trainer in public safety management, a policy developer in the area of disaster projects management. An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Environmental Audit (EA) Lead Auditor registered with NEMA Kenya. A Member of the Environmental Institute of Kenya (EIK), A practicing member of Professional Trainers Association of Kenya (PTAK), A member of the Project Management Institute (PMI) the regulatory organization of the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK)